SEO is a long-term effort, and without clear metrics it is hard to know whether your work is paying off. That is what SEO KPIs are for: measuring what happens on Google, understanding what visitors do once they reach the site, and deciding on next steps based on data rather than impressions.
The problem is that between Google Search Console, Google Analytics 4 and rank tracking tools, you quickly end up with dozens of figures. In this article, we sort through them: which metrics to track, where to find them, and above all how to read them without jumping to conclusions.
What is an SEO KPI?
A KPI, or Key Performance Indicator, is a metric that measures performance. In SEO, it tells you whether your site is gaining or losing visibility on search engines, and whether that visibility brings anything to your business.
Not every figure is a KPI. A good metric is tied to a goal: being seen more on certain searches, attracting more qualified visitors, generating more enquiries. Before tracking anything, you need to know what the site should deliver for the business.
SEO KPIs can be grouped into four families, matching the stages of a user’s journey: being indexed, being seen, being clicked, then converting.
Google Search Console metrics
Google Search Console is Google’s free tool that shows how your site appears in its search results. Its Performance report brings together four main metrics, which can be viewed by query, page, country or device.
Impressions
An impression is counted each time a link to your site appears in the results seen by a user. It is the raw visibility metric. Rising impressions mean that Google is showing your site for more searches or more often, even if this does not yet translate into visits.
Impressions are often the first metric to move after publishing new content or optimising a page. They show that Google is starting to associate the page with certain queries.
Clicks
Clicks are the number of times a user clicked through to your site from Google’s results. They are the direct link between your visibility and your traffic. By looking at clicks per query, you can see which searches actually bring visitors to your site.
Click-through rate (CTR)
CTR is the ratio of clicks to impressions. It shows whether your result makes people want to click. A low CTR on a well-ranked page often signals an unappealing title or meta description, or a result that does not match what the user is looking for.
CTR should always be read with position in mind: it is naturally higher at the top of the page than on page two. It also depends on what Google displays around your link, such as a map, ads, videos or an AI-generated answer.
Average position
Average position shows where your site appears on average in the results for a query or a page. It is useful for following a trend, but misleading when looked at globally. A page that starts appearing for new, loosely related queries can pull down the site’s average position while its visibility is actually growing.
It is better to look at position query by query, focusing on the searches that matter for your business.
Indexing metrics
A page that is not indexed cannot appear in Google. Search Console’s Page indexing report shows how many pages of your site are indexed and which ones are not, along with the reason: crawled but not yet indexed, duplicate page, blocked page, redirect error, page not found.
The right approach is not to aim for 100% of pages indexed, as some pages do not need to be, such as thank-you pages or technical pages. Instead, check that the important pages (your services, your articles and your contact pages) are indexed, and watch for sudden increases in errors.
The URL Inspection tool lets you check a specific page: is it indexed, which version has Google kept, when was it last crawled. It is the first check to make when a recent page does not appear in the results.
Google Analytics 4 metrics
Search Console stops at the click. To find out what visitors do once they reach the site, you need Google Analytics 4.
Sessions from organic search
In GA4’s acquisition reports, the Organic Search channel group covers visits from search engines, excluding paid ads. This is your SEO traffic. How it changes over time, compared with the same period the previous year to smooth out seasonal effects, shows whether your SEO is bringing in more or fewer visitors.
GA4 and Search Console figures never match perfectly. The two tools do not measure the same thing: a click is not a session, and GA4 does not count visitors who decline analytics cookies. Compare trends rather than exact values.
Key events
Key events, previously called conversions in GA4, are the actions that have value for you: submitting a contact form, clicking a phone number, requesting a quote, buying, signing up. They have to be configured, as GA4 does not guess them.
This is the metric closest to your business goals. Rising organic traffic with no increase in enquiries is a reason to look at the pages attracting that traffic and at their ability to convert.
Engagement
GA4 also measures the engagement rate, that is, the share of sessions in which the visitor stayed a minimum amount of time, viewed several pages or triggered a key event. Its inverse is the bounce rate in GA4. Low engagement on a page receiving a lot of organic traffic can point to content that does not match the search, or a page that is slow and hard to read on mobile.
Visibility in AI tools
Some searches now go through assistants such as Claude or ChatGPT, or through AI-generated answers directly in Google. This new behaviour calls for new metrics, which are still imperfect.
In GA4, you can spot visits coming from these assistants by looking at referral traffic sources, such as claude.ai or chatgpt.com. This traffic is often still modest in volume, but it is worth tracking its growth and the pages it reaches.
On Google’s side, clicks and impressions from AI-generated answers are counted in Search Console’s Performance report, without being broken out separately. To get an idea of your presence in assistants’ answers, the simplest approach is still to regularly test the questions your customers ask and note whether your business is mentioned, and alongside whom. We cover this approach in detail in our article on GEO.
How to read your SEO KPIs correctly
Compare like with like
SEO moves slowly and many businesses are seasonal. Comparing one week with the previous one tells you very little. Look instead at trends over several months, and compare a period with the same period the previous year.
Read the metrics together
A single metric rarely tells the whole story. Rising impressions with stable clicks may mean you are appearing for new queries, still far down the results. Falling clicks with a stable position may come from a change in the results page, for example an AI-generated answer appearing above the links. It is by cross-referencing impressions, clicks, CTR and position that you understand what is going on.
Segment by page and by query
Site-wide averages hide what matters. A page in decline can be masked by another that is growing. To decide what to do, look at the pages and queries that matter for your business, one by one.
Connect SEO to business results
Traffic is not a goal in itself. The right final KPI is the one that speaks to the business: enquiries, quotes, calls, sales. A site that attracts fewer visitors but more qualified prospects is making progress, even if the traffic graph goes down.
Which KPIs to track for your situation?
For a small business just starting out, a few metrics are enough: are the important pages indexed, are impressions and clicks growing on searches related to your trade and your town, and is the site generating enquiries. A monthly check on these three questions is better than a fifty-line dashboard nobody reads.
For a larger site or an online shop, it becomes useful to track metrics by page type, monitor indexing closely and measure the value of conversions coming from organic traffic.
In any case, if the figures are falling for no obvious reason or you do not know where to start, an SEO audit lets you review the technical side, content and indexing before setting goals. And if you would rather delegate the tracking and the work, our SEO agency in Montpellier can manage your SEO with you, based on these metrics.